Advantages and Disadvantages of an ESOP as an Exit Strategy

Reading Time: 5 minutes

Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) have become an increasingly popular way to give employees ownership in their companies while also offering significant benefits to exiting owners. Consider the following statistics highlighting the popularity of ESOPs and how they can benefit employees, owners, and companies:

Growth and Prevalence:

There are approximately 6,500 ESOPs presently in the U.S., employing about 14 million workers.
ESOPs managed nearly $1.4 trillion in assets in 2023 – a significant increase over the previous few decades.

Performance of ESOP Companies:

ESOP companies experience a 2.5% higher annual growth rate in sales and employment, compared to non-ESOP companies.
ESOP companies are 25% more likely to stay in business compared to non-ESOP companies.
According to research from the National Center for Employee Ownership (NCEO,) productivity tends to increase by 4% to 5% in the year after an ESOP is established.

Employee Benefits:

ESOP participants have been shown to accumulate 2.5 times more wealth in their retirement accounts than employees in traditional retirement plans.
Employees at ESOP companies enjoy a 5-12% higher pay than their counterparts at non-ESOP companies.

Longevity and Resilience:

During economic downturns, ESOP companies are four times less likely to lay off employees compared to non-ESOP companies.
ESOP companies are more likely to survive longer, with a longevity rate 5 times greater than that of non-employee-owned businesses.

Corporate Stability and Succession:

Over 69% of ESOP companies report that the ESOP helped to enhance the company’s culture and long-term focus.

Community Impact:

ESOP companies contribute significantly to local economies, often by keeping jobs and economic activity rooted in their communities. This helps reduce the risks associated with relocations or closures.

These statistics highlight how ESOPs can benefit both companies and employees, driving greater stability, profitability, and long-term sustainability.

ESOPs are commonly used in exit planning, especially for family-owned businesses, because they allow owners to sell to employees, ensuring business continuity. Here are the key advantages and disadvantages business owners should consider when considering an ESOP as an Exit Strategy:

Advantages of an ESOP as an Exit Strategy:

Tax Benefits:

For sellers, there are significant tax advantages. For example, using a Section 1042 Rollover, owners of US owned C-Corporations who sell 30% or more of their stock to an ESOP can defer capital gains taxes by reinvesting in qualified securities.
Contributions of stock to the ESOP are tax-deductible; and in S-Corporations, the portion of ownership held by the ESOP is not subject to federal income taxes.
ESOP-owned companies can, moreover, deduct contributions to repay the ESOP loan, which lowers the business’ taxable income.

Continued Legacy:

Business owners can preserve their company’s legacy by selling to employees. This ensures continuity in management and culture, which is often important for owners who want their business to maintain its hard fought identity.

Improved Business Performance and Value:

Giving employees an ownership stake in the business can improve the business’ overall performance and enhance the value of the company over time. Employees become part-owners in the ESOP, which often leads to increased motivation, productivity, and loyalty.

Flexible Financing:

ESOPs can be structured with seller financing, allowing the owner to receive proceeds over time often at more favorable terms than a direct sale to a third party.

Gradual Exit:

ESOPs allow the owner(s) to sell the business in phases, offering flexibility to owners who want to transition out slowly rather than leaving the business all at once.

Disadvantages of an ESOP as an Exit Strategy:

Complexity and Costs:

Setting up an ESOP involves legal, financial, and administrative costs. The initial setup and ongoing management of the ESOP require specialized expertise, which can be costly.
2. Financing the Buyout:
An ESOP usually requires borrowing to finance the purchase of the owner’s shares, which can strain the company’s cash flow. If not managed carefully, this debt could pose financial risks to the business.

Dilution of Ownership:

If the ESOP is gradually buying shares, it may create a complex ownership structure where the former owner and the employees have split or changing ownership percentages over time.

Employee Risk:

If the company’s performance declines, employees who hold significant stock through the ESOP may see their retirement savings diminish. This adds an element of financial risk for employees who are now partial owners.

Management Challenges:

The company may need to implement more formal management processes and governance structures. In some cases, the need for transparency with employee-owners can limit operational flexibility.

Limited Market:

ESOPs are generally only suitable for stable, profitable companies. Smaller businesses with inconsistent cash flow may struggle to finance the transaction or maintain the structure long-term.

In summary, an ESOP can be a powerful exit strategy, offering tax benefits, the ability to preserve company culture, and the potential to improve employee engagement, but it comes with complexity, potential financial strain, and risks that need to be carefully evaluated.

ESOPs work best for companies that are financially stable, have a strong management team, and are committed to long-term employee ownership and are an increasingly popular exit strategy for established businesses with an EBIT of $1 million or more, as this threshold ensures that the payments to retiring employees will be sufficient to incentivize them without being a financial burden for the company.

About Greater Prairie Business Consulting, Inc.:

Greater Prairie Business Consulting, Inc. is an award-winning, national consulting practice serving entrepreneurs, small to mid-sized privately held and family-owned businesses and middle market companies of any type with revenues between $1 million and $250 million. The firm helps small, mid-sized and middle market companies maximize their performance and exit.

Greater Prairie Business Consulting, Inc. can be reached by calling 1-800-828-7585 or emailing info@gpbusinesssolutions.com.

About the Author:

James J. Talerico, Jr. is an award-winning author, speaker, and a nationally recognized small to mid-sized (SMB) business expert.

With more than thirty- (30) years of diversified business experience, Jim has a solid track record and an A+ BBB rating helping thousands of business owners across the US and in Canada tackle tough business problems to improve the performance of their organizations.

His client success stories have been highlighted in the Wall St. Journal, Dallas Business Journal, Chicago Daily Herald, and on MSNBC’s Your Business. He was named “Texas Business Consulting CEO of the Year,” by CEO Today Magazine, identified as a “Top 10 Management Consulting Entrepreneur to Watch in 2023” by Entrepreneur Magazine, was listed among the “10 Most Visionary Companies to Watch in 2023” by Inc. Magazine, and has also been ranked among the “Top Small Business Consultants” followed on Twitter.

For more than half a decade, Jim was a regular guest on “The Price of Business,” a nationally syndicated radio program on Bloomberg Talk Radio and has also appeared as a subject matter expert on many FOX Radio interviews. He is a regular contributor to several blog sites and has frequently been quoted in publications like the New York Times, Dallas Morning News, Philadelphia Inquirer, The Entrepreneur’s Review, and on INC.com, in addition to numerous, other industry publications, radio broadcasts, business books, and Internet media.

Jim received a Gold “Stevie Award” for “Thought Leader of the Year,” a Gold “Stevie Award” for “Media Hero of the Year During Covid” and a Bronze “Stevie Award” for “Best Entrepreneur” in the Category of “Business and Professional Services” at the American Business Awards ® in New York City. The competition received more than 3,700 nominations and is the premier accolade for business excellence in the US honoring organizations of all sizes and industries. Jim also received an “Outstanding Leadership Award” at the Money 2.0 Conference for his contributions to the financial services industry.

Jim is the author of “8 Steps to Becoming an ETHICS FOCUSED ORGANIZATION,”™ a small business certification program that utilizes a unique eight – (8) step approach for strengthening ethics in any organization. The certification program won the Better Business Bureau’s “Torch Award for Ethics” for the North – Central Texas Region, the International Better Business Bureau’s “ Torch Award for Ethics,” and a Gold “Stevie Award” for “Ethics in Sales” at the International Sales & Customer Service Stevie Awards ®. Participants who complete this certification program are eligible to receive eight – (8) continuing education units from the University of Texas’ Division of Enterprise Development.

Jim received his Certified Business Exit Consultant (CBEC) ® designation from The International Exit Planning Association (IEPA) to help entrepreneurs, small business owners, family businesses, and middle market companies maximize their business exit, and he received his certification in succession planning from the ASPE.

Jim is also a Certified Management Consultant (CMC) ® and an active member of the Institute of Management Consultants.

Share This: